Good “Illusion Of Order” By Bernard E. Harcourt Book Review Example

“Illusion of Order” is one of the famous books in which author Bernard Harcourt argues about the impact of the broken-windows theory on the policing in the United States. The author divided the book into three critiques, namely empirical, theoretical and rhetorical in order to evaluate the evidence of social disorder and serious issues of crime. Harcourt explains a causal sequence of the broken-windows hypothesis and the factors that led to the contribution of crime drop in the country. Such factors include falling unemployment rates, organizational reforms implemented by the policing department, demographic factors and increased surveillance. In the theoretical critique section, Harcourt states various types of behaviors, such as tax evasion, police brutality, fraud and safety violations. The author mentions about the shortcomings of the broken –windows theory and the role of policing strategies in categorizing criminal groups. He gives an account of the concept of disorder, which is a problem in itself.
The third section analyzes about the influence of the theory and the importance of harm principle in justifying legal intervention. The book is impressive as it contains both empirical and theoretical analyzes in addition to methodological prescriptions. The author maintains a simple tone throughout the book, making it easy to read and understand. Harcourt’s debate about broken-windows policing hosts a variety of arguments, which help to predict the future of policing. However, the author overstates the practicalities of the broken-windows theory outside the United States, in terms of policing practices. The book interests the readers who are passionate about policing, such as policy makers as it offers various practical suggestions. The book is a must read for academicians pursuing courses in criminal law as it offers a great insight on various concepts and principles related to broken-windows policing theory.