Free Hardin Vs Singer Essay Sample

Hardin vs. Singer

One of the social issues in the world, today facing mankind is the issue of poverty. There exist several alternatives options on how to handle poverty-related incidences. However, most people find themselves torn in a decision dilemma wanting to help and those who are completely devoid of what to do. Garrett Hardin's and Peter Singers, similarly were caught up in such a decision dilemma however I try to agree with Peter Singer to some degree Singer’s belief and thought through article advocates for sacrifice on luxuries to the rich nations and use the same to uplift live in the poverty stricken nations. His belief originates from the moral reasoning that human lives is equally significant and have equal value. Furthermore, people may not choose where to be born to determine their destiny. Singer’s (2011) argued that lets the government and individuals able to assist in the famine relief and other disasters to the poor nations. I agree with him totally in the area he cites we need to help ourselves first before giving support to other countries and support should be based on sacrificing our luxuries (Cherry, 2011). However not similar to Garrett Hardin's view is we should stop completely from perpetuating culture of assisting the poor because such support is not sustainable ways of solving poverty issues. Otherwise, the rate of population’s growth is causing a lot of strain to natural resource utilization everywhere. For instance, the total giving by united states to charitable organizations in the year 2012 is equivalent to 2% GDP of America $ 316.23 billion (Greene and Joost, 2000,p.11). Improving other people's lives make you feel good it create a sense of satisfaction and being happy seeing lives saved because of an individual input. However, the charity should never be an obligation but should be done out of free choice. I feel Singer is correct, let us support others if we can. In addition, it snot prudent to support first the developing nations while ignoring the poor people in American first- charity begins at home. Let us empower out people first, identify structures that are making them poor and support them to come out of the menace (Singer, 2011).

References

Cherry, K. (2011). Hierarchy of Needs – Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs. Psychology – Complete Guide to Psychology for Students, Educators & Enthusiasts. Web. 30 Mar. 2011. <http://psychology.about.com/od/theoriesofpersonality/a/hierarchyneeds.htm>.
Greene, R., and Joost, E.(2000). The 48 Laws of Power. New York: Penguin
Singer, P. (2011). The Singer Solution to World Poverty. Utilitarian Philosophers. Web. 30 Mar. 2011. <http://www.utilitarian.net/singer/by/19990905.htm>.